GRENADA, Miss. (AP) — A Mississippi man whose daughter died after he left her in a hot car was released from jail without bail Tuesday, with the possibility that the second-degree murder charge against him could be reduced.
Grenada Municipal Judge Rusty Harlow ordered the release of 25-year-old Joshua Blunt on his own recognizance after city prosecutor Jennifer Adams requested the move and a friend and a police detective testified he wasn’t a flight risk.
Blunt wept as he emerged from the Grenada County jail a few minutes later, embraced by relatives and friends who had offered support during the brief court hearing.
Adams told Harlow that Grenada officials want to reduce the charges against Blunt from second degree murder, punishable by up to life in prison, to culpable negligence, a felony punishable by up to a year in prison.
However, Harlow said he wanted to hear from Grenada County District Attorney Doug Evans, who prosecutes felonies in the county, before making that decision.
Blunt’s lawyer, Carlos Moore, has said he will fight that lower-grade felony charge.
Janette Fennell, founder and president of the Kansas-based KidsAndCars.Org, said that between 1990 and 2015, charges were brought in 45.5 percent of cases involving the deaths of children in hot cars in the U.S.
The group’s figures show there were 706 cases of children dying in hot cars for those 25 years. Some cases involved multiple deaths.
The district attorney was present for Blunt’s hearing but didn’t participate. Evans later told The Associated Press that the correct procedure would be for city officials to drop the original murder charge and enter a new culpable negligence charge. Then he said the district attorney could decide whether to present the case to the grand jury.
Evans said he has seen some information from the investigation, but couldn’t comment on whether he believed Blunt knew the child was in the car.
Shania Caradine, Blunt’s daughter, died Thursday after she was left in her father’s car outside the 333 Restaurant in Grenada.
Blunt’s lawyer says she was there for about four hours. The lawyer said Blunt and a co-worker found the infant in the car, took Shania inside the restaurant and put cool towels on her to await an ambulance that took her to the University of Mississippi Medical Center Grenada. Grenada County Deputy Coroner Jo Morman said physicians at the hospital tried unsuccessfully for hours to revive the baby.
She was the second Mississippi child to die from heatstroke in a vehicle within two weeks. No charges have been brought against a parent in the other case.
Supporters and family members erupted in claps and cheers in the courtroom after Harlow ordered Blunt’s release, with one person shouting, “Oh yes!”
John Archer, who said he’s Blunt’s brother-in-law, said he and his wife, Patricia Archer, helped raise him.
“We think it was fair because he’s working two jobs and he’s never been in trouble,” John Archer said. “He’s just trying to support his family. It’s just an accident.”
Archer said Blunt was called in to work Thursday on a day he had been scheduled to be off. Archer speculated that the change in routine distracted Blunt from dropping off his daughter at the home of Shanice Caradine’s mother.
Shanice Caradine is the child’s mother and Blunt’s girlfriend.
Among supporters present Tuesday was Allyson Worsham, who owns the 333 Restaurant. She called Blunt a good worker who had been “so proud” when his daughter was born.
“This has been a horrible tragedy,” Worsham said. She thanked a jail guard for watching Blunt, saying he had voiced thoughts of suicide after his daughter’s death.
“Shanice sent a message to me that she loves him and that she and Shania forgive him,” Worsham said.